Sunday, February 21, 2010

Sexuality in Early Spain

In class this week, the focus was gender relations in Spain. Looking previously into Spaniard conquests in Latin America and the changes they brought with them, one would assume that women had little rights in Spain, as they did in their newly conquest territories. However, I was surprised to read that the women had many legal rights (some which they took advantage of). This was probably because of the model of Ferdinand and Isabella, where Isabella seemed to be the “head of the household” because she kept her land separate and had much more of it than her husband.

Focusing on the article by Edward Behrend-Martinez titled, "Manhood and the Neutered Body in Early Modern Spain", it was interesting to read about how “manhood” was defined in early Spain. I was surprised to read how much pressure was on men to prove their masculinity, physically and in conduct. The pressure to have the ability to perform sexually and be potent male was extremely heavy because it seemed to be the whole community’s duty to find out about a man’s private life and broadcast it to the whole community. They felt it necessary to “warn the public” of a male’s incomplete anatomy or lack of ability to perform in reproduction, so that he would not fool an unsuspecting woman into marrying “imperfect man”. I did not realize how private our society is until I read how transparently public this society was involving the intimate details of a man’s and couple’s private life. This public openness was used by the Catholic Church as a way to “control the public sphere to participate in the economy of sexual reputation”, and to curtail men from deceitfully getting into relationships with women who assumed their competence.

It was also interesting to read about the case of Juan, who was born a hermaphrodite and considered an outcast in the community. S/he was considered a monster and an outcast. When Juan showed interest in living as a male, it worried family members, who viewed it as unnatural. Even though it seemed Juan chose his own sexuality, as a man, the court ordered Juan to live as a female and required Juan to remain celibate. I felt sorry for Juan that the court chose his sexuality instead of accepting the way Juan wanted to live, whether it be male female, or as both.

Reading from the Spaniards’ point of view was good because it gave me the whole picture about the influences early Latin America had and the reasons as to why and how they ruled when they came to Latin America.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Justifying Slavery

This week’s readings and discussion was centered around the Latin American slave economy, in particular, Kris Lane’s article titled, “Captivity and Redemption: Aspects of Slave Life in Early Colonial Quito and Popayan”. It was interesting comparing slavery in Latin America to slavery in North America, specifically the South, and finding how similar the two experiences were in two very different places. Also, the video shown in class depicting the transportation of slaves across the Atlantic was hard to watch. It is sickening to realize that human beings underwent that much torture and humiliation. I wondered if those white slave traders had consciences. Then, I read about the reasons in which they justify these enslavements in order to squash any amount of guilt they may possibly encounter. The slave traders and buyers (owners), justify slavery by claiming that they are doing a service to them by saving them from the barbarity and tyranny of Africa where they lived as Christ less savages who should feel it a privilege to be captured and be able to live in a world with order and religion. However, when you look at the way they are treated from capture until their deaths, there is anything but order and Christianity.

These female slaves were clearly viewed as humans because they were given the important jobs of nursing their master’s children, proving that they realized that these Africans shared the same physical bodies. It is so contradicting to me as to how they were viewed as sub-human-savages who were beaten or killed for misbehaving and used for the sole purpose of labor and reproduction for profit, yet was perfectly fine to feed their master’s children from their own “African” milk.
It is difficult to fathom how these slave traders and owners cold-heartedly viewed and treated their African slaves, and makes me wonder if they had any guilt for their treatment. Then, viewing the ways they justified slavery shows me that they did have some (even if very little) guilt because of the ways they justified their acts by claiming to be their saviors from a cruel and savage Africa.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Primary Account of Mesoamerican Births

This week’s post will be about the readings on Nahuatl Speeches and Dialogues, more specifically, the excerpts from the midwife’s speeches from the Florentine Codex, Book VI. This speech discusses the rituals involved with the birth of a child and the differences in preparation of male and female babies. Mesoamericans viewed women’s “duties” as a sort of war making. Sweeping the floor was making war with chaos, for example, in addition to making war in giving birth. This act was something to be proud of and was not viewed upon lightly, for women who had survived labor were highly regarded as bravely birthing a male physical warrior or a female warrior for the home. When the baby appears, the midwife shouted war cries, “which meant the woman had fought a good battle, had become a brave warrior, had taken a captive, had captured a baby”.

Much like everyday life to these Mesoamericans, births are also very much paralleled by gender. When a male child was born, his umbilical cord was buried under the battle field, signifying the life he will live ruled by battle to protect his land. Conversely, a female child’s umbilical cord was buried under the hearth, signifying that the female was not to go anywhere outside the home, for her sole duty was maintaining the household.

It is interesting that the midwife stresses more to the female that her work will be hard and that she will fatigue and work hard to provide for the household, than to the male who will fight on the battlefield. This shows how much importance is placed on the women’s work and how important their “battles” are.

By today’s standards, this “putting women in their place” concept of women’s purpose to take care of the house would be seen as grotesquely sexist and demoralizing, yet in the Mesoamerican’s world, this system worked for them and each were seen as equally important. Saying that women need to be in the kitchen is just as sexist as protesting that they need to be out working with men. However, it is refreshing to read firsthand accounts about these people and how they are constantly working together for the betterment of their society.

Sunday, January 31, 2010

Impact of the Spanish Invasion on Andean Women

This week in class we discussed how important gender parallelism was in the culture of the Andeans. Everything was divided into distinct, completely separate male and female spheres. Men and women were seen as completely opposite as represented by the separate spheres that each sex represented such as sun and moon, lightning and rain, morning and evening, and sky and earth. These views worked for these people and constituted a nice flow for the workings of everyday life.

Lines of descent were according to sex. Daughters were linked primarily to their mothers and sons to their fathers, forming matrilines and patrilines. Likewise, surnames were passed on from one gender parent to the same gender child. There were also parallel lines of inheritance where the mother passed down her lands to her daughter upon marriage and death. These lands received by women, remained the woman’s own property upon marriage. Effective labor units involved both the male and female working together on different tasks within the home and community. There were distinct line of these male and female tasks that were essential for the maintenance and reproduction of the household, society, and the empire itself.

However, everything changed when the Spanish invaded the Andes. The Spaniards strove to immediately uproot everything of the Andean society for the sole purpose of their own wealth and prestige. According to Spanish law, women were legally minors. In order for women to obtain goods or property, they had to obtain permission from their male “tutors”, or husbands, and could not dispose of it on their own. On the other hand, land received by women from their mothers or anyone could be sold by their husbands without their permission. If that wasn’t demeaning enough, women were sometimes locked up by colonial administrators and forced to weave and spin for their own profit. They were essentially used as slaves not only for economic gain but for sexual use also. While women were seen essentially as equals sexually in the pre-Spanish invasion and permitted to engage in sexually activity, as long as both parties were willing, they were now seen as sex-slaves and concubines to the Spanish conquistadors. Many of the men that did not abandon their families because of the harsh conditions of the militia service took advantage of this new society of male dominance. They now had a sense of ownership of their female relatives, essentially pawning them to the intrusive, destructive Spaniards.

It is really sad to see the decent that women underwent during the invasion of the Spaniards. Everything was working cohesively for them and their families until the Spanish turned everything upside-down. Women equality is supposed to constantly move forward and it is disheartening to see it take a huge step back for the furtherance of Spain and its greedy conquistadors.

Sunday, January 24, 2010

Week 1

This week’s reading by Mary Elizabeth Perry, With Stones and Roasting Spits: Moriscas and a Multidisciplinary Methodology for Studying Women in Golden Age Spain, was very thought provoking a really opened my mind to people of different beliefs and why they have those beliefs. It also got me thinking as to how much I judge other cultures and presume I know why they do certain things, when in actuality, there is no way to understand pure motives and beliefs unless you are an actual member of that culture or group. More specifically, the issue Perry brings up about women in certain cultures that wear veils. She writes that in the 16th century, Christian authorities banned Moriscan women from wearing their veils. These authorities believed they were doing the women a favor by freeing them from the men’s authority and control. The Christians and so many people in today’s world view veils as some kind of restraint and use of power by men. While much of that may be true, there is so much more to it than that. Those women who wore veils, no doubt, felt most comfortable with one on her head for personal modesty preferences. It also held symbolic cultural significance for the women who were being forced to put away their own identity and customs and conform to a different, unwanted Christian culture. The veils signified tradition that their hearts continued to cling to and was a way for the women to silently show their opposition to the persecution by the Christians.

Today, when we look at pictures of veiled Muslim women in the Middle East, we feel sorry for them just because they do not fit our contemporary views of how women should dress; sexy. We subconsciously think that those women wish that they could dress more “fashionable” or “beautiful” but are restrained by their domineering husbands. While it is true that Muslim women dress almost completely covered because of their religion, which is male dominated, it is their culture, they do not know anything different, and it is what they are most comfortable in.

This article has really got me thinking about how I compare other cultures to my own and judge the “rightness”, so to speak, of the things they do by my own traditions and the way I was taught. It caused me to broaden my views of other cultures and not to judge them “right or wrong” according to my beliefs, but instead to consider different worldviews and try to understand where they are coming from.